I'm afraid I don't know enough of these show to vote, but here's my two cents anyway.
The 4400, while not exactly bad, was mostly disappointing and easily forgettable. Skip it. Doctor Who s3 was, imo, better that s2.
Also, you should totally consider Deadwood. Because Deadwood is great and needs more fic.
(And if you decide to go for Lost s5, tell me if it was worth the price or if I should just wait for some kind relative to give it to me as a Christmas present:))